Neem Premium om alle advertenties te verbergen
Berichten: 108   Bezocht door: 123 users
01.03.2014 - 11:47
I recently witnessed a CW between Bums and TC. Madara has a surprise expansion as turk where he likes to cap Belarus.In this CW the result of this was ukraine could not complete his wall first turn due to the presence of the AT near to Kiev. Richtofen promptly left the game resulting in absolte chaos. This has led me to the question, do the rules need revising? and What exactly are the rules concerning wallblocking(wf) on turn 1 ?

In Madara's tournaments the rules specifically state that the opposition player cannot enter the opposing player's territory, so that is explicit for his tournaments. In this CW his expansion would be a clear violation of this rule. However I believe Madara to be an honest player and he stated he would not have attacked. So again another question, do we leave it up to the honour of the various player that indeed if such a violation occurs; we presume accidentally; the game simply continues without the player being attacked? Or it is simply forbidden to enter enemy territory? Strictly forbidding players from enemy territory on turn 1 seems like the clearest way of solving any such issues ,So in this instance Madara would simple have to rework is expansion. I think the competitive players should have their say, after all they are the ones who compete! This was indeed a CW , the pride and joy of atwar.

N.B I believe option 1: depending on players' honour open up a 'can of worms' .What happens on turn two? can he now wall on turn two, or should he now be wallblocked(wf), after all many walls are broken on turn 2 anyway. This become confusing.
----
"When you connect to the silence within you, that is when you can make sense of the disturbance going on around you."
― Stephen Richards
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:16
Madara act bad like dirty his fault he have wf cap like 10 time now to cws
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:20
The exact same thing happened again, once it can be a coincidence, not twice. I think he knew exactly what he was doing .....
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:21
AlexMeza
Account verwijderd
I LOLd So hard.
I'm pretty sure it wasn't intentional. Richthofen got a free win for them, it's that guy's fault and no one else's. I wasn't there but if what you said is true, then yeah. Probably the rest of the clan *cough* hi juger *cough* will assume Madara is a cheater, I don't know.
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:24
Ales he didn't even apologize for wf'ing. He also been doing this to others. leaving was valid on my part.
----
Deutsch überwältigt

Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:28
The funny was he stayed there 10 turn and turn 3 or 4 attacked austria lol.The zekrom you was there like a pro left i clap him fo doing this.And remember madara is he who say to his turnaments no wallfuq no entering to enemy land turn 1.


Dont have anything to say just i see a dirty r9 player.
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:28
The way the finished the game is completelly wrong, first the wf wasnt intentional, second, if madara promessses that he wont attack kiev, there is no problem and the game can carry on as if nothing happend, 3rd there is no rule that wfing first turn is forbiden, we just dont play like that, because is extremly dirty, but that still not a reason to give win to the other team, unless is a tournament and the rules say so.
so this cw should be tied or carried on, and if bums would have lost, the only person to be blamed about ir would be richtofen for leaving the game before players have come to a decision
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:29
From what i know, accidentally wallfuck on 1st turn is not a problem, player cant attack that city but will attack the wallfucked wall like he should and the game continue normally.

But if for that expansion to work any unit has to remain in oponents home country then it is illegal.Just my opinion.
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:32
Geschreven door Richthofen, 01.03.2014 at 12:24

Ales he didn't even apologize for wf'ing. He also been doing this to others. leaving was valid on my part.


by leaving the game you just proved how unexperient and skilless player you are, you have absulutelly no reason for ragequiting on a serious game like a cw ...good players wouldnt ragequit because of a dirty move,they would actually fight him back and try to beat him under those circumstancies. being wallfucked on the first turn, dont mean you will lose the game, but as you just showed everyone, for you it means...
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:32
Geschreven door lOrd pOnteZ, 01.03.2014 at 12:28

The way the finished the game is completelly wrong, first the wf wasnt intentional, second, if madara promessses that he wont attack kiev, there is no problem and the game can carry on as if nothing happend, 3rd there is no rule that wfing first turn is forbiden, we just dont play like that, because is extremly dirty, but that still not a reason to give win to the other team, unless is a tournament and the rules say so.
so this cw should be tied or carried on, and if bums would have lost, the only person to be blamed about ir would be richtofen for leaving the game before players have come to a decision

But pontez say me if someone unknow for you like a r3 wf you turn 1 who says he will not attack.Rich dont know madara and he just think is a dirty r9 thats all.
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:33
Geschreven door Khal.eesi, 01.03.2014 at 12:29

From what i know, accidentally wallfuck on 1st turn is not a problem, player cant attack that city but will attack the wallfucked wall like he should and the game continue normally.

But if for that expansion to work any unit has to remain in oponents home country then it is illegal.Just my opinion.

It isnt first time madara wf to cws.. is like the 7th one.
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:35
Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:32

Geschreven door lOrd pOnteZ, 01.03.2014 at 12:28

The way the finished the game is completelly wrong, first the wf wasnt intentional, second, if madara promessses that he wont attack kiev, there is no problem and the game can carry on as if nothing happend, 3rd there is no rule that wfing first turn is forbiden, we just dont play like that, because is extremly dirty, but that still not a reason to give win to the other team, unless is a tournament and the rules say so.
so this cw should be tied or carried on, and if bums would have lost, the only person to be blamed about ir would be richtofen for leaving the game before players have come to a decision

But pontez say me if someone unknow for you like a r3 wf you turn 1 who says he will not attack.Rich dont know madara and he just think is a dirty r9 thats all.


LMFAO rich dont know madara?? OMG dont defend him with nonesense arguments, everyone knows madara, and even if he doesnt know at least hear what he had to say, rich basically cryed his ass out of the game
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:36
AlexMeza
Account verwijderd
Geschreven door Richthofen, 01.03.2014 at 12:24

Ales he didn't even apologize for wf'ing. He also been doing this to others. leaving was valid on my part.

I would reply to this but look at pontez' post.
Also, did he REALLY wallfuck in 7 CWs? lol atleast I never saw it. If it happened before, I would have heard of it or people would bitch a lot about it or make a thread.
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:36
You dont even know what you talking about juggers
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:37
Geschreven door Guest, 01.03.2014 at 12:36

Geschreven door Richthofen, 01.03.2014 at 12:24

Ales he didn't even apologize for wf'ing. He also been doing this to others. leaving was valid on my part.

I would reply to this but look at pontez' post.
Also, did he REALLY wallfuck in 7 CWs? lol atleast I never saw it. If it happened before, I would have heard of it or people would bitch a lot about it or make a thread.

He saied alone to game 'is only my 4th time i wf to cws first turn' when a spectaror wrote 'madara like always wf'
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:37
Geschreven door lOrd pOnteZ, 01.03.2014 at 12:36

You dont even know what you talking about juggers

I do
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:38
Just all you ask the Stryko,Chill or someone other who show this cw
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:40
AlexMeza
Account verwijderd
Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:37

Geschreven door Guest, 01.03.2014 at 12:36

Geschreven door Richthofen, 01.03.2014 at 12:24

Ales he didn't even apologize for wf'ing. He also been doing this to others. leaving was valid on my part.

I would reply to this but look at pontez' post.
Also, did he REALLY wallfuck in 7 CWs? lol atleast I never saw it. If it happened before, I would have heard of it or people would bitch a lot about it or make a thread.

He saied alone to game 'is only my 4th time i wf to cws first turn' when a spectaror wrote 'madara like always wf'


Oh, so on the 4 CWs, he did it on purpose, and attacked next turn?
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:41
Geschreven door Guest, 01.03.2014 at 12:40

Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:37

Geschreven door Guest, 01.03.2014 at 12:36

Geschreven door Richthofen, 01.03.2014 at 12:24

Ales he didn't even apologize for wf'ing. He also been doing this to others. leaving was valid on my part.

I would reply to this but look at pontez' post.
Also, did he REALLY wallfuck in 7 CWs? lol atleast I never saw it. If it happened before, I would have heard of it or people would bitch a lot about it or make a thread.

He saied alone to game 'is only my 4th time i wf to cws first turn' when a spectaror wrote 'madara like always wf'


Oh, so on the 4 CWs, he did it on purpose, and attacked next turn?

Dont know and dont care how can someone wf in cw 4 times without purpose?
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:42
AlexMeza
Account verwijderd
Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:41

Geschreven door Guest, 01.03.2014 at 12:40

Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:37

Geschreven door Guest, 01.03.2014 at 12:36

Geschreven door Richthofen, 01.03.2014 at 12:24

Ales he didn't even apologize for wf'ing. He also been doing this to others. leaving was valid on my part.

I would reply to this but look at pontez' post.
Also, did he REALLY wallfuck in 7 CWs? lol atleast I never saw it. If it happened before, I would have heard of it or people would bitch a lot about it or make a thread.

He saied alone to game 'is only my 4th time i wf to cws first turn' when a spectaror wrote 'madara like always wf'


Oh, so on the 4 CWs, he did it on purpose, and attacked next turn?

Dont know and dont care how can someone wf in cw 4 times without purpose?


I don't know? Maybe he does same expansion and the AT is always next to kiev? lol that doesn't matter, what matters is that he won't attack next turn, so there's no cheating.
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:45
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Oh, so on the 4 CWs, he did it on purpose, and attacked next turn?

Dont know and dont care how can someone wf in cw 4 times without purpose?


I don't know? Maybe he does same expansion and the AT is always next to kiev? lol that doesn't matter, what matters is that he won't attack next turn, so there's no cheating.

But still hilarius,if your cap wfed you will not get angry?All you put your selvs in rich situation all you will moan like me.
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:48
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:45

Oh, so on the 4 CWs, he did it on purpose, and attacked next turn?

Dont know and dont care how can someone wf in cw 4 times without purpose?


I don't know? Maybe he does same expansion and the AT is always next to kiev? lol that doesn't matter, what matters is that he won't attack next turn, so there's no cheating.

But still hilarius,if your cap wfed you will not get angry?All you put your selvs in rich situation all you will moan like me.


yes thats what matters, and anyone would be angry, but only the noobs would ragequit and cause this mess to happend. and if you want me to explain you whats my point, we can make a duel, and you can wf me or even better i wont wall my cap on the first turn and i wanna see you winning that game.
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:48
AlexMeza
Account verwijderd
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:45

Oh, so on the 4 CWs, he did it on purpose, and attacked next turn?

Dont know and dont care how can someone wf in cw 4 times without purpose?


I don't know? Maybe he does same expansion and the AT is always next to kiev? lol that doesn't matter, what matters is that he won't attack next turn, so there's no cheating.

But still hilarius,if your cap wfed you will not get angry?All you put your selvs in rich situation all you will moan like me.

No I wont :/ I'll be like "LOL Wtf. What did you do? Don't attack next turn". Quitting turn 2 IN A CW is pretty dumb.
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:53
I have to agree with Lord Pontez throughout this thread. Also Madara is a completely honest and sensible person, I'm sure he didn't mean anything by it and only used the Air Transport to attack Belarus. I have seen many other players use this tactic and they don't attack Kiev turn 2 either. Richtofen shouldn't of left, he should of took Madara's word for it and then had he actually attacked Kiev, it would of been okay to leave turn 2.

Only thing that surprises me here is the fact Madara knows fully well about not putting units in enemy homeland territory. Like the rule he mentioned in his tournaments, however like I mentioned above I'm sure he didn't mean anything by it and was simply his expansion to take Belarus.
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:53
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Geschreven door lOrd pOnteZ, 01.03.2014 at 12:48

Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:45

Oh, so on the 4 CWs, he did it on purpose, and attacked next turn?

Dont know and dont care how can someone wf in cw 4 times without purpose?


I don't know? Maybe he does same expansion and the AT is always next to kiev? lol that doesn't matter, what matters is that he won't attack next turn, so there's no cheating.

But still hilarius,if your cap wfed you will not get angry?All you put your selvs in rich situation all you will moan like me.


yes thats what matters, and anyone would be angry, but only the noobs would ragequit and cause this mess to happend. and if you want me to explain you whats my point, we can make a duel, and you can wf me or even better i wont wall my cap on the first turn and i wanna see you winning that game.

I dont care who wins or lose is just a game.This i care is to play right and no dirty like madara does
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:56
Geschreven door Trooper21, 01.03.2014 at 12:53

I have to agree with Lord Pontez throughout this thread. Also Madara is a completely honest and sensible person, I'm sure he didn't mean anything by it and only used the Air Transport to attack Belarus. I have seen many other players use this tactic and they don't attack Kiev turn 2 either. Richtofen shouldn't of left, he should of took Madara's word for it and then had he actually attacked Kiev, it would of been okay to leave turn 2.

Only thing that surprises me here is the fact Madara knows fully well about not putting units in enemy homeland territory. Like the rule he mentioned in his tournaments, however like I mentioned above I'm sure he didn't mean anything by it and was simply his expansion to take Belarus.

But why to do it?if is like it when i am uk wf berlin as biltz with my trans,or use AT as spain to cap benerulux and wf paris.Those are all dirty espacially when you do it at rule and dont follow it.
----
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:58
Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:53


I dont care who wins or lose is just a game.This i care is to play right and no dirty like madara does


Silly child, he wasn't playing dirty at all. He was expanding to take Belarus, we all know Madara well he's not the type to wf and take the cap the turn after.

Want to know what I really think? I think Richtofen knew he wasn't going to win the cw anyway and was looking for a cheap excuse to leave the game early. No other sensible player would of left. I think everyone else will agree with me on this one too.
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 12:58
Madara plays dirty please dont deny this accusation
----
Deutsch überwältigt

Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 13:00
Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:56

But why to do it?if is like it when i am uk wf berlin as biltz with my trans,or use AT as spain to cap benerulux and wf paris.Those are all dirty espacially when you do it at rule and dont follow it.


No no no, it is nothing like that lmfao, now you're just exaggerating everything. I think the place he put the AT was the only place where he could launch his Infs from to take Belarus. Place that AT anywhere else and he would of range failed.

To be honest, if you think about it Madara's expansion could of costed him early because he overspent his first turn. This proves Rich had every chance of winning that battle against Madara, if he had continued playing.
Laden...
Laden...
01.03.2014 - 13:01
Geschreven door Trooper21, 01.03.2014 at 12:58

Geschreven door JUGERS2, 01.03.2014 at 12:53


I dont care who wins or lose is just a game.This i care is to play right and no dirty like madara does


Silly child, he wasn't playing dirty at all. He was expanding to take Belarus, we all know Madara well he's not the type to wf and take the cap the turn after.

Want to know what I really think? I think Richtofen knew he wasn't going to win the cw anyway and was looking for a cheap excuse to leave the game early. No other sensibleplayer would of left. I think everyone else will agree with me on this one too.

Lol you dont show it i was france and taked from spain italy,germany expnsion good,uk had just belgium and nl,rich dont fail had rc rs rwn finalnd 2 cities and poland
----
Laden...
Laden...
atWar

About Us
Contact

Privacy | Servicevoorwaarden | Banners | Partners

Copyright © 2024 atWar. All rights reserved.

Volg ons op

Verspreid het nieuws